Job Centre - www.financeasia.com
FinanceAsia Home  
   Tuesday 01 Dec 2009
Get the best financial information delivered daily direct to your inbox
Home > Job Centre
 Job Centre

TOP STORIES

JP Morgan or Stan Chart: which is the better employer?

COMMENTS

Stan Chart is great, if you want your whole career to be in Asia. JPM gives you better opportunities to work in Western markets.  Read all comments »

In the battle to become Asia’s best bank, J.P Morgan and Standard Chartered are emerging from the rubble as clear favourites.

But which firm would you rather work for? The global powerhouse or the Asian champion?

J.P.Morgan recently topped The Banker magazine’s annual list of the strongest 1,000 international banks, moving up from fourth place a year earlier.

The rankings, which have run since the 1970s, are based on capital strength, or the amount of Tier 1 capital held. J.P.Morgan was helped by its takeover of Bear Stearns and Washington Mutual.

Standard Chartered, unlike British rivals RBS and Lloyds, hasn’t needed a government bailout, and raised US$1.8bn from investors last year to increase capital and increase its buffer against bad loans.

And although its workforce is 2,500 people lighter than late last year, it is hiring again in Singapore and Hong Kong. Recent results show that these two centres performed particularly well for Stan Chart’s wholesale banking unit.

Which bank is performing better in your mind? And which is the best place to build your career? Let us know below.

COMMENTS

bulldozer, Information Technology,  Thu 02 Jul 09

JPM probably. no one has touched the aspect of pay so let me tell an interesting story. we had a JPM guy come in for an interview (i'm at a local bank) cos the there were some aspects that he was not happy about. this person had only 1 year's work experience in TOTAL.

when my HOD interviewed this person, the pay that was asked for was MORE than my HOD because that was his equivalent one in JPM!!!

how's that for feeling crappy if you were my HOD?!?!

obviously, we couldn't afford this person...

Add your comment »

Kitty, Risk Management,  Thu 02 Jul 09

JPM of course. SCB pale in comparison. For fresh grad, one learn way more in JPM, or hardly anything, maybe corporate management / office politics,in SCB. Wonder why there are so many media coverage on how "good" SCB is. Maybe its PR is working harder than the others.

Add your comment »

ItsAJoke, Information Technology,  Thu 02 Jul 09

yeah, SC wins it anyday. After all, where else can I get the pleasure of having to kiss (a***) someone at office, have an excellent social life (watching my colleagues) and be heard (someone's always overhearing what I say).

Add your comment »

Simon Mortlock, Information Technology,  Thu 02 Jul 09

Well, this debate is certainly stirring you up! How about writing an anonymous monthly blog about life inside your bank?

eFinancialCareers is looking for financial professionals to write anonymous columns - providing honest, opinionated perspectives on employment, job hunting and careers.

We already run several of these articles on our Singapore website. For examples, please see:

http://news.efinancialcareers.sg/Blogs_ITEM/newsItemId-18797
http://news.efinancialcareers.sg/Guest_ITEM/newsItemId-18070
http://news.efinancialcareers.sg/Guest_ITEM/newsItemId-19684

If you think you can do the same, please email: apac.editor@efinancialcareers.com

Thanks,
Simon Mortlock
Editor

Add your comment »

Jeff, Information Technology,  Sun 05 Jul 09

What about HSBC?

Add your comment »

Graduating, Student,  Sun 05 Jul 09

Speaking from a graduate perspective, I think starting a career with SC as a graduate is more stable than the blood-boiling analyst programme at JP. Morgan. I personally know many 07 graduates, who managed to get into Bulge Bracket banks, got fired this year. If you want stability and all-rounded banking exposure, SC is the way!

Add your comment »

khanduri,  Sun 12 Jul 09

What a joke.... whosoever thought of comparing a bullock-cart with a TGV

Ask a logical question, where does Standard Chartered senior management come from... The answer would be from other Bulge Bracket banks or consulting firms... SC does not have confidence itself  to fill senior positions with it's own long time employees as it knows that the banks offers a mediocre work force.

Just because you never went out to sea and hence never faced a shipwreck does not make you a good sailor. By that logic most of the banks of mainland China or other legacy domestic banks in India etc would be the best banks as they got impacted even less by the financial crisis. In fact Standard Chartered got saved ironically by the age old quote "sometime dumb is the smartest thing to do". As credit derivatives or likes of that were beyond the sophestication of Stanchart.

Where ever Standard Chartered took even little risk they got hammered. Look at the case of Whistle jacket the SPV of Stanchart or else take a look at the performance of it's FX options business in the year 2008.

By contrast JP Morgan has survived while very much playing in the rough waters and smartly exiting in good time.

Add your comment »
< Prev   1, 2   Next >

ADD YOUR COMMENT

* Mandatory fields
Your name
Your field
Your Comment*
You have 1200 characters left
Image verification* ( What is this? )
Enter the code shown below or Sign in / Register to skip this step.
Disclaimer: All comments must adhere to eFinancialCareers Ltd’s Add your comment rules.
To complain about a comment, please email editor@efinancialcareers.com.