Job Centre - www.financeasia.com
FinanceAsia Home  
   Monday 13 Oct 2008
Get the best financial information delivered daily direct to your inbox
Home > Job Centre
 Job Centre

TOP STORIES

Has Singapore finally overtaken HK as a finance centre?


COMMENTS

For instance every 6 months or so the Straits Times runs an article about the 10's of thousands of professionals seemingly leaving Hong Kong in droves and beating down the door begging to be let into Singapore.  Read all comments »

Do we now have conclusive proof that Singapore is trouncing Hong Kong in finance?

The city state has leapfrogged its northern rival to become Asia’s number two financial hub, according to the recently released Mastercard Worldwide Centres of Commerce Index. Only Tokyo now lies between Singapore and Asian domination.

If you once dismissed Singapore as an annoying financial upstart, now’s the time to change your mind and build your banking career in the Lion City.

The fresh findings come as a bitter blow to anxious bankers and policy-makers in Hong Kong who are desperate to make money from the Chinese market, while maintaining HK’s standing in international finance.

And that’s not the end of Hong Kong’s troubles. Mercer’s new Quality of Living survey ranks Singapore at 32 in the global league table of big cities – two places better than last year – while Hong Kong languishes at a lowly 70.

So if Singapore is better for banking and better for living, why work in Hong Kong? Pack your bags for Singapore below.

COMMENTS

e, Operations,  Thu 12 Jun 08

Don't think I can agree with that. Singapore as a capital market is still very backward compared to HK and the rest...

Add your comment »

@sia, Information Technology,  Thu 12 Jun 08

A quote from MasterCard website:

"....2008 Worldwide Centre of Commerce Index offers a comprehensive comparative ranking of 75 of the world’s leading global cities and their instrumental role in driving the global economy, including an evaluation of their stregths and challenges across several key measurement dimensions"

There is nothing (straightly speaking) to deal with the status of financial centre in Asia. If you are working in IBD/Capital Market, you will definitely know the ranking of Tokyo/HK/Singapore/Shanghai.

This is just another spin from the media.

Add your comment »

Jo, Information Services,  Thu 12 Jun 08

Sia - yes, the main ranking was for commerce.

but there were also separate specific rankings for individual sectors, including financial services. in the finance ranking in Asia the results were.
1) Tokyo
2) SG
3) HK

Add your comment »

poyko, Retail Banking,  Thu 12 Jun 08

It all depends really on what part of banking you're working in. in private banking maybe I am better off staying put in SG

Add your comment »

Belinda, Research,  Thu 12 Jun 08

Doesn't matter so much - teh size of the Japanese dmestic market means neither city is really challenging tokyo for no 1 top spot

Add your comment »

Noise, Credit,  Thu 12 Jun 08

Singa-bore - dull jobs, dull place

Add your comment »

mei, Insurance,  Thu 12 Jun 08

I have experienced both banking and other financial services (like insurance) from Singapore and Hong Kong. In terms of marketing innovation, I think that HK is more innovative whereas Singapore is more as a follower. Moreover, banking services in Singapore is less customer-centric and also less technology-advanced.

I really don't think that Singapore can replace HK in terms of being a center of commerce or financial hub.

Add your comment »

ace, Capital Markets,  Thu 12 Jun 08

if you look at singapore 2 yrs ago, then yeah, HK is ahead. I just went there, i think it is on par with HK now (or HK has slipped).

Add your comment »

recruiterraj, HR & Recruitment,  Fri 13 Jun 08

Topic sounds to me like "China trouncing India's IT outsourced market" and "India trouncing China's Mass production outsourced market".

Add your comment »

jharteam,  Tue 24 Jun 08

Hong Kong is part of the PRC already. From a perspective as a country, it has the strongest backings from the PRC.  The sheer magnitude of size has already outshines Singapore.  By pointing out Singapore has already surpassed HK as a financial center is really ridiculous; so, Singapore has the ability, resources and size to surpass the PRC?  Don't joke yourself, dudes.  Lot's of Singaporean corporations are operating in the PRC now; 'cause they know it will not be profitable to stay put in Singapore. It is Singapore that always attempts to compare with HK (for years!!).  For HK people, they really don't give a damn; cause they know they 've got the right stuffs.  Singapore can try to mimic HK (which they have been doing for years). In the end, A tiny "country' like Singapore can only be a major financial center in their dreams.  China (which HK will be a part of) will be the ultimate financial center in Asia.

Add your comment »
< Prev   1, 2   Next >

ADD YOUR COMMENT

* Mandatory fields
Your name
Your field
Your Comment*
You have 1200 characters left
Image verification* ( What is this? )
Enter the code shown below or Sign in / Register to skip this step.
Disclaimer: All comments must adhere to eFinancialCareers Ltd’s Add your comment rules.
To complain about a comment, please email editor@efinancialcareers.com.